The farmer meets the corporation

The Sunhara Wal-Mart project at Hapur, Uttar Pradesh is a joint collaboration between the Sunhara India project, a non-profit initiative for women empowerment in agriculture and handicrafts, and Wal-Mart, the world’s biggest retailer as part of its CSR activities. Started in August 2011, the two year venture entails training of farmers and direct sourcing of their produce to Wal-Mart stores across northern India. Such projects, a direct concurrence of the Indian common man and an international corporation should be able to give crucial pointers of the impact of foreign players on the Indian grassroots. Now, more than ever, as the issue of FDI in multi-brand retail is at the forefront of political and economic debate.

The town of Hapur and the adjoining farmlands are a major supplier of staple vegetables all over north India. Consisting mainly of small farmers with small to medium landholdings, Hapur has a large population existing solely on agriculture. Sunhara, funded and supplied by Wal-Mart both with technology and manpower, identified small farmers, with landholdings less than one acre and gave them training and instructions on cultivation. In return, the farmers could sell their produce to them at collection centres at rates equal or more than the local markets called mandis. This made it convenient to the farmers as they no longer had to go to the mandi and empowered the women to also take part in selling the produce.

This initiative was not new to the farmers. Indian retailers and food processing companies have been using the same process for decades now. At Hapur itself, the villagers joining the Wal-Mart initiative are familiar with brands like Big Bazaar, Easy Day and Mother Dairy who also have such collection centres. Mother Dairy in fact, has had a presence in Hapur for around twenty years. It is not uncommon for farmers to have undergone training by three or four different companies. Although these initiatives have brought about new techniques and innovations to farming, the farmers are still vary of committing themselves completely to the organised sector for a variety of reasons. 

While local mandis will accept all the produce from the farmer and provide him instant remuneration, the Sunhara initiative will only accept a small amount of his produce. Wal-Mart sources only around one ton of produce a day from all the farmers combined making it difficult for farmers to harvest and transport in such small quantities.  Also remuneration for the sale is delayed by a month or more which can cause a lot of inconvenience to the marginal farmers. The organised players have very strict quality standards resulting in more than half the produce being rejected. To meet these standards, the farmers are forced to harvest before they normally do to cater to their demands. Even then, a farmer still has to go to the mandi to sell a good proportion of his harvest, most of it of the lower grade. A farmer’s wisdom understands that transporting higher quantities of various grades together will result in much less wastage than transporting small quantities of a single grade.

From the perspective of the company, only a minuscule percentage of its sourcing is done at these collection centres. The bulk is still sourced from the mandis where there is more flexibility and variety. The vegetables have a 2-3 day lead time to reach the retail outlets thus necessitating the purchase of not yet ripened produce. This initiative has not introduced any improvement in transportation and storage facilities.

Other than improvement in techniques and empowerment of women due to the convenience involved, this initiative has done nothing to improve some of the inherent problems of agriculture in India such as huge wastages, fluctuating prices and the financial insecurity of farmers. As a part of a social service initiative, no company, neither an MNC, nor Indian retailers seem to be ready to commit the investment required to bring about any long term change in the distribution system. Only when the scale of such operations are sufficiently high to justify investments in logistics and storage will there be sufficient economies of scale to make it attractive to the common farmer. Until then, factors the inability of even the large companies to ensure timely payment raises questions on the commitment they are willing to show.

Unless there is long term strategy and vision, such initiatives will only become another attempt that gets caught up in the malaises that affect our society today like inefficiency and corruption. This would be unfortunate for all involved, as there is a lot even an MNC can learn from the wisdom of the common man that would be lost.